Shelter Island, NY – a hidden paradise with a relaxed vibe

Sandwiched between North Fork and the Hamptons, Shelter Island is best known for its serene beaches, historic neighborhoods, and laid-back lifestyle. This secluded island is not accessible by car. To get here, you will have to take a five-minute ferry ride from Greenport or North Haven, but this commute is definitely worth it. Visitors and residents often describe Shelter Island as “un-Hamptons”, it is quiet and less crowded, and that's what makes it so appealing. 

Shelter Island offers an abundance of fantastic beaches, marinas, and charming residences. Here is one: an 8-bedroom, 5-bathroom home with a private boat slip. The listing defines this house as a 'true oasis'. Once you step inside, you will find a beautiful living room with elevated ceilings and a fireplace. Large windows bring tons of light into each bedroom. The recently renovated kitchen includes top-of-the-line appliances and marble countertops.

The outdoor space has everything you need for the perfect summer retreat: a spacious yard, a pool with a retractable cover, a basketball hoop, and a hot tub. The future owner can use this home in the summer or stay here all year round. This house can also make a great Airbnb rental with a 4.4 percent annual return. 

Here is another Shelter Island find: a 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom ranch-style home. This house has two major advantages: a huge living space with no staircases and easy access to the sprawling outdoor area. With a gunite pool, bluestone terrace, and beautiful green lawns, this home makes the perfect weekend getaway destination. 

Inside, you will find three spacious bedrooms with water views. Once you move in, you can convert the office into an additional bedroom or use it as your work-from-home space. The living room with a skylight creates a welcoming and relaxing atmosphere for you and your guests. If you decide to list this home as a short-term rental, your annual return will be around 4 percent. 

Shelter Island is often listed among the best weekend getaways near New York City. The average home in this area sells for $1.8 million. The competition among buyers is low, which means you have the opportunity to negotiate the asking price. Contact us for more details on your future home on Shelter Island.